• About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Cookies Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Affiliate Disclosure
Sunday, November 22, 2026
  • Login
Imroze Pakistan
  • Home
  • National
  • International
  • Business
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
  • Blog
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • National
  • International
  • Business
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
  • Blog
No Result
View All Result
Imroze Pakistan
No Result
View All Result
Pakistani farmer working in an agricultural field amid debate over farm taxation.

Experts Question Using Agriculture’s GDP Share to Set Tax Targets

October 8, 2026
0

Agricultural experts have cautioned against using agriculture’s share of GDP as a direct measure of its tax potential.

They said agricultural output should not automatically be treated as taxable income.

Farm profitability depends on several factors. These include crop prices, yields, input costs, weather conditions and market conditions.

Experts said the distinction was particularly important for Pakistan’s millions of small farmers. Many face volatile prices and may sell crops below official or expected rates.

GDP Output Does Not Equal Farm Income

Mahmood Nawaz Shah, president of the Sindh Abadgar Board, said the taxation debate should distinguish between economic output and actual farm income.

He cited wheat as an example.

Pakistani Actors Join Humanitarian Mission for Palestinian Families in Jordan

During the 2024-25 wheat season, the government announced prices of around Rs4,000 per 40 kilograms and later Rs3,900.

However, farmers in major producing areas sold wheat at substantially lower rates, Shah said.

“If the farmer sells below his cost or expected price, how can that production be treated as taxable income?” he asked.

Shah said GDP measures the value of production. Taxation, however, should ultimately reflect profitability.

He said the same issue applied to cotton, maize, rice and sugarcane.

Production, yields and market prices can change significantly from one year to another.

Shah rejected the argument that agriculture’s GDP share should determine its tax contribution.

Instead, he suggested using average farm profitability over five to seven years to estimate the sector’s realistic tax potential.

Small Farms Complicate Tax Collection

Shah also questioned whether agriculture’s large workforce should automatically translate into high tax potential.

Agriculture supports a significant share of Pakistan’s employment. However, its income is distributed among millions of workers and farmers.

Muhammad Ali Iqbal, president of Concave Agri Services, said the challenge was particularly significant because more than eight million farmers are engaged in agriculture.

Most farmers operate relatively small holdings, he said.

As farm sizes decline, applying a uniform taxation model becomes increasingly difficult.

Farmers also face uncertain revenues because crop prices can change sharply between planting and harvest.

Iqbal said taxation should consider three key factors: input costs, yield and output prices.

Input costs have risen because of taxes and other market pressures. Yields also remain constrained by seed quality, technology gaps and other production challenges.

Farmers, meanwhile, have limited control over market prices.

Technology Could Improve Tax Assessment

Iqbal said the situation differs for commodities with government-supported prices or more predictable markets.

He identified price uncertainty, transparency and price discovery as major issues.

The government cannot accurately determine taxable farm income without reliable production and price data, he said.

Iqbal suggested using technology to improve the process.

Satellite imagery, remote sensing and improved yield-estimation systems could help authorities estimate cultivated areas and crop production.

Such systems could provide data at district and tehsil levels. Authorities could then compare the estimates with farmers’ declarations.

Iqbal said this approach could create a more credible link between actual production and taxable income.

Experts Call for Digital Farm-to-Market Records

Aamer Hayat Bhandara of Agriculture Republic also called for digitising the agricultural value chain.

He proposed creating transaction records that track agricultural produce from farms to markets, processors and consumers.

Bhandara suggested that commodities entering mandis should be weighed through electronic systems.

The quantity and quality of each transaction could then be recorded digitally.

He said a farm-to-fork digital trail could help determine the actual volume and value of agricultural trade.

It could also reduce the scope for under-reporting.

Agriculture’s Tax Role Extends Beyond Farmers

Iqbal said the tax debate should also consider the wider agricultural supply chain.

Much of the economic value generated by agriculture is captured after crops leave the farm.

Food companies, processors, exporters and manufacturers buy agricultural commodities as raw materials.

They then add value before selling finished products.

For example, food processors may purchase tomatoes, chillies and other crops. The resulting economic activity may eventually be recorded under manufacturing or other sectors.

Iqbal said agriculture should therefore not be examined in isolation when assessing its contribution to tax revenue.

Informal Transactions Remain a Challenge

Iqbal also highlighted the fragmented nature of agricultural transactions.

Many farmers and agricultural small and medium-sized enterprises operate outside formal documentation systems.

Farmers may also receive payments late and lack the financial or digital skills needed to maintain detailed records.

This makes it harder for taxpayers and authorities to establish actual annual income.

Iqbal said the government should also review whether existing regulations discourage formalisation in agriculture and the food sector.

He pointed to compliance requirements involving the Federal Board of Revenue as one potential challenge.

Businesses sourcing raw materials from farmers who may not be tax filers can face additional compliance burdens, he said.

The experts argued that a more accurate agricultural taxation system would require better production data, transparent pricing, digital transaction records and greater formalisation across the supply chain.

Previous Post

Pakistani Actors Join Humanitarian Mission for Palestinian Families in Jordan

Next Post

PSX Reverses Early Gains as KSE-100 Falls 682 Points

Related Posts

Finance Minister Muhammad Aurangzeb chairs the Steering Committee meeting on power sector regulatory reforms in Islamabad.
Business

Aurangzeb Calls for Comprehensive Power Sector Reforms to Cut Electricity Costs

November 21, 2026
French mural artist CHIFUMI with officials at the unveiling of an Ajrak-inspired mural at Arts Council Karachi.
Business

French Artist CHIFUMI Unveils Ajrak-Inspired Mural in Karachi

November 20, 2026
- Pakistan Stock Exchange, UNICEF and Pakistan Business Council officials at the Ring the Bell for Children ceremony on World Children's Day 2026.
Business

PSX, UNICEF and PBC Ring Bell to Promote Children’s Rights

November 20, 2026
- Iranian rial currency exchange rates against the US dollar, Pakistani rupee, Saudi riyal and UAE dirham.
Business

Iranian Rial Weakens Against Dollar, Dirham and Pakistani Rupee

November 20, 2026
- Gold bars and silver bullion displayed amid falling precious metal prices in Pakistan.
Business

Gold Prices Plunge by Rs15,400 per Tola in Pakistan

November 20, 2026
- Oil prices and crude oil market outlook amid Middle East supply risks.
Business

Oil Prices Steady as Market Surplus Outlook Offsets Middle East Supply Risks

November 19, 2026
Next Post
Pakistan Stock Exchange trading board as KSE-100 index declines in intraday trading.

PSX Reverses Early Gains as KSE-100 Falls 682 Points

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent News

- Students showcase science projects and innovative ideas during Beaconhouse Jubilee Campus SCICON 7.0 in Karachi.

Sindh Government Urges Students to Prepare for AI-Driven Future Through Science and Innovation

November 22, 2026
- Tajikistan Ambassador Sharifzoda Yusuf Toir at a Pakistan American Cultural Center reception in Karachi.

‘Karachi Is My Home’: Tajik Ambassador Praises City’s Vibrant Atmosphere

November 22, 2026
- Daniel Vettori and Kane Williamson at Kavya Maran and Anirudh Ravichander’s wedding reception.

Daniel Vettori, Kane Williamson Attend Kavya Maran’s Wedding Reception

November 22, 2026
Harry Kane undergoes ankle surgery after suffering a ligament injury during Bayern Munich's Bundesliga match against Cologne.

Harry Kane Undergoes Ankle Surgery, Vows to Return for Bayern Munich’s Crucial Season Run-In

November 22, 2026
Bahrain reports an attack on an industrial facility amid tanker incidents in the Strait of Hormuz.

Bahrain Reports Iranian Strike on Industrial Facility as Tankers Come Under Attack in Strait of Hormuz

November 22, 2026

Imroze Pakistan is your trusted digital news platform, delivering timely and credible updates from across Pakistan and around the globe. From breaking headlines to insightful features on politics, economy, society, and international affairs — we aim to inform, engage, and empower our readers with facts that matter.

Gallery

British-Pakistani Shatters A-Level Records with 6 World Titles
British-Pakistani Shatters A-Level Records with 6 World Titles
inDrive Wins Gold at Dragons of Pakistan Awards, Secures Spot in Dragons of Asia Competition
inDrive Wins Gold at Dragons of Pakistan Awards, Secures Spot in Dragons of Asia Competition
Sindh CM Marks Independence Day at KCCI, Announces Major Water Projects
Sindh CM Marks Independence Day at KCCI, Announces Major Water Projects

Popular Post

PM Shehbaz Sharif Unite for a Powerful Partnership: Pakistan and Turkey’s Future Plans Revealed!

PM Shehbaz Sharif Unite for a Powerful Partnership: Pakistan and Turkey’s Future Plans Revealed!

August 3, 2023
“Strategic Synergy: Faraz-ur-Rehman Advocates Industry-Education Collaboration for National Growth”

“Strategic Synergy: Faraz-ur-Rehman Advocates Industry-Education Collaboration for National Growth”

October 27, 2023
UN chief calls for ‘immediate’ ceasefire in Gaza

UN chief calls for ‘immediate’ ceasefire in Gaza

January 16, 2024
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Cookies Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Affiliate Disclosure

© 2026 Imroze Pakistan - All Rights Reserved

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • National
  • International
  • Business
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
  • Blog

© 2026 Imroze Pakistan - All Rights Reserved